Posted on Jan 04, 2011 - 11:54am by admin in cars-first transportation, Economic Waste
Junkers, as in these Junkers.
As DbC has previously said, even in a nation-state as propaganda-drenched as this one, it takes some work to find a mainstream shibboleth less true than the claim that cars-first transportation is an equalizing force in American society.
In reality, even ignoring their core purpose of further enriching corporate shareholders, the distribution of automobiles among U.S. product users is profoundly unequal.
Turns out, this inequality is a central outcome of the recently concluded round of “cash-for-clunkers” handouts.
Demographic researcher Dante Chinni (whose Patchwork Nation book is quite useful, by the way) reports:
Since the “cash for clunkers” program whipped through auto dealers this summer, the debate about it has raged. Depending on whom you talk with, it was one of the most successful government stimulus programs in history, or it was a $3 billion boondoggle that ultimately had little impact. “Success” is a hard thing to judge, but when you look at where the money went in Patchwork Nation, one thing seems clear: The program benefited the wealthy the most and arguably did little for poorer, struggling communities. Using data from the federal government, we looked at where the nearly 700,000 cash-for-clunkers transactions took place and found that three community types in particular cashed in: the largely suburban “Monied ’Burbs,” the growing and diversifying “Boom Towns,” and the collegiate “Campus and Careers” counties. These three types all have higher-than-average median household incomes, and in general, they’ve fared better during the recent economic challenges.
This is more important evidence that: a) much of what has passed for a bailout under the Democratic Party has been a supply-side boondoggle, and b) cars-first transportation is a huge obstacle to economic and ecological sanity.
2 Responses
Baby Huey
January 5th, 2011 at 9:44 am
1You’re failing to appreciate how vertically-integrated the Petrocracy is. I mean, most everyone in modern civilization has, or thinks they have, a vital interest in the automotive economy. It’s like an “inverted tyranny” rather than a tyranny from on high. We’ve been totally subverted, people on every rung of the economic ladder, from the lordliest oil tycoon to the humblest strip-mall clerk who depends on easy motoring to bring in customers. Until you address that conundrum, you’re mostly barking up the wrong tree. Sure, the presumptive statesmen and other leaders should know better, as time goes by, but the commoners share the blame. We who live car-free and yet pay general-fund taxes for roads (used to be gas taxes only) are suffering a breach of the social contract, forced to bankroll our own destruction, but we have to argue the case as a minority that needs protection from democratic rule, because that’s what we are.
admin
January 12th, 2011 at 3:13 pm
2Baby Huey, I appreciate the point you’re making, but don’t agree with it. Ordinary people have never been permitted to participate in transportation politics. Neither you nor I can say for sure what they’d choose to do if they were allowed to understand and redress the situation. But we know for sure that will not happen without a big and clear-minded fight to blow open the topic.
As to vital interests, it is of course one thing to think you have one and another to actually have one.
Likewise, it’s my analysis that most would-be critics tend to overstate the depth of “car culture” among the general population. Most of the reason that people accept the thing as inevitable is that the cars-first system has already been built. Facts on the ground, as the killers say in Israel.
Rebuilding our towns to demote automobiles would require a New New Deal. I can think of quite a few people who would have a vital interest in that.
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Flash MP3 Player
Here is the Music Player. You need to installl flash player to show this cool thing!
DbC Topics
Blogroll
Recent Comments
Tags
Search DbC
Calendar
Meta
This site powered by WordPress and the Rapid Access Theme.
This page generated with 36 queries, in 1.188 seconds.