DbC Hall of Mirrors: Blaming Everybody/Nobody

dogma As I said over at The Consumer Trap, in the aftermath of the Deepwater Horizon disaster, there is an uncontrolled gusher of conventional “everybody’s to blame” dogma parading around passing itself off as serious social criticism.

This phony, knee-jerk analysis is merely the flip-side of the capitalist dogma insisting that demand for products arises exclusively from spontaneous popular wishes and unsullied technological innovations only, no corporate manipulation involved. It’s an excuse and a denial, in other words.

What we need now is realistic descriptions of and remedies for the institutionalized, class-based decisions that continue to impose petro-intensive living on human societies. Swallowing the familiar trope that the main problem resides in your looking glass is a step away from, not toward, such realism.

Meanwhile, this new DbC page is dedicated to collecting examples of the mental virus that denies the existence of an overclass and blames “us” all instead. Please feel free to send in cases you encounter.

DbC Hall of Mirrors Inductees:

Chris Clugston:  With zero evidence to back his assertions, Clugston claims “Americans ‘just don’t get it’ regarding the unsustainable nature of our American way of life,” and that anger at BP is a “self-righteous” distraction from the deeper fact that we have met the enemy and it is us.

Peter Fowler:  “If BP Is Evil Then So Are We All,…because we demand the oil they are forced to take these sorts of risks to get.” So, in Fowler’s telling, coerced acceptance equals policy origination.

Joanna Weiss:  Weiss frets, “I couldn’t help but wonder how much I should hate myself.”  She talks of “our oil-drenched lifestyles” as if we all asked for them and would refuse to consider alternatives, if given a choice.  Joanna thinks cars-first transportation comes from a “culture of expansion,” not corporate capitalist dictatorship. Evidence for any of these claims? None, and none needed. They are merely true by statement, since they replicate conventional business-society tropes.

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
10 years ago

The difference between that sort of blame-the-victim thinking and the line of the bad guys from The Magnificent Seven, “If God did not want them sheared, he would not have made them sheep,” seems a mere difference of degree rather than one of kind. Maybe in current movies that kind of line is given by the “good guy” instead!

free transit
10 years ago

excellent blog – we are linking you – see us on twitter @freepublictrans